logo
Hepatitis C - Class Actions Settlement
HomeSearchContact UsFrançaisPrivacy

Claimants:
Essential Information
Claimants:
Additional Information
Claimants:
Loss of Income / Loss of Support / Loss of Services
Periodic Re-Assessment by the Courts
Appeals
Documents
Forms
Contacts and Links
Annual Reports
Administrator


2003 Annual Report

$firstSched && $thisSched <= $lastSched) { print 'Previous | '; } ?> Table of Contents = $firstSched && $thisSched < $lastSched){ print ' | Next'; } ?>

Schedule P - PriceWaterhouseCoopers LLP Actual Costs and Budget for Year 4

Ms. Bonnie A. Tough
Hodgson Tough Shields DesBrisay O’Donnell
Barristers & Solicitors
Suite 550 36 Toronto ST
TORONTO ON M5C 2C5

May 22, 2003

Dear Ms. Tough:

Compensation for Hepatitis C Infected Persons

Your Ref: 1024
Our File Number: 20-73-26335-07-001 (to March 2003)
20-73-26335-08-001 (from April 2004)

Analysis of Fees for the 15 Months Ended March 2003

Further to our discussion with Ms. Julia Evans of your office, we are pleased to set out below an analysis of our fees for the 15 months ended March 2003, separating the first three months from January to March 2002 from the remaining 12 months.
For the purpose of the analysis below, we have valued our time for each separate period using the proposed billing rate of $212 per hour.

Service

January to
March 2002

April 2002 to
March 2003

Finalize 2001 income tax calculations   51.5
Develop and finalize 2002 income tax calculations   40.5
Develop initial 2003 income tax calculations   12.5
History file updates for previous payments 18.5 16.0
Minor software maintenance / upgrades 19.1 11.1
Billings and administration   7.0
Interpretation, JC reporting and other assistance 4.1 16.1
     
Total 41.7 154.7
Hourly Billing Rate $212 $212
Disbursements $1,093 $467
Total Amount Charged (Before GST) $9,933 $33,264

As previously explained in our letter of April 8, 2003, the total amount charged for the 15 months ended March 2003 equals $43,197, which is virtually identical to the interim billings rendered over this 15 month period.

Proposed Budget for the 12 months Ended March 2004

In developing our proposed budget for the 12 months ended March 2004, we have referred in part to the professional time incurred during the 12 months ended March 2003, as set out above. However, we have also made the following significant adjustments:

  • We reduced the time expected to be incurred finalizing the income tax calculations for the current year and developing preliminary income tax calculations for the following year. This is because all provinces have now switched to a tax on income basis from a tax-on tax basis, and the complexity associated with these changes has now been addressed in the software; and

  • Based on recent inflation trends, we used an average billing rate of $220 per hour (increased from $212 per hour up to March 2003).
    As a consequence of the above changes, our proposed budget for the 12 months to March 2004 decreases from $32,797 (being the value of the time incurred during the 12 months ended March 2003) to $22,000, before disbursements and GST. Adding an estimate of $500 for disbursements, we respectfully request a proposed budget for the 12 months ended March 2004 of $22,500 (before GST), as calculated below.

Service (prior years in brackets)

April 2002 to
March 2003

April 2003 to
March 2004

     
Finalize 2002 (2001) income tax calculations
51.5
5.0
Develop & finalize 2003 (2002) income tax calculations
40.5
20.0
Develop initial 2004 (2003) income tax calculations
12.5
15.0
History file updates for previous payments and Minor
software maintenance / upgrades
27.1
35.0
Billings and administration
7.0
10.0
Interpretation, JC reporting and other assistance
16.1
15.0
 
Total
154.7
100.0
Hourly Billing Rate
$212
$220
Value of Professional Time
$32,797
$22,000
Disbursements
$467
$500
Total Amount Charged (Before GST)
$33,264
$22,500

General

We trust that the above will be satisfactory to you. Should further assistance be required, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned.

Yours very truly,

Daniel M. Edwards
Financial Advisory Services

DME/ke

cc: Mr. Ronald Jackson
PricewaterhouseCoopers Ottawa

cc: Ms. Laura Bruneau
The 86-90 Hepatitis C Claims Center

Top
 

Disclaimer